All Americans: 1974

 Offense
WR-Patrick McInally, Harvard
WR-Peter Demmerle, Notre Dame
TE-Bennie Cunningham, Clemson
T-Kurt Schumacher, Ohio State
T-Robert Simmons, Texas
T-Marvin Crenshaw, Nebraska
G-John Nessel, Penn State
G-Kenneth Huff, North Carolina
G-John Roush, Oklahoma
C-Geoff Reece, Washington State
C-Steve Myers, Ohio State
QB-Steve Joachim, Temple
QB-Steve Bartkowski, California
RB-Joseph Washington, Oklahoma
RB-Archie Griffin, Ohio State
RB-Anthony Davis, Southern California

 Defense
L-Mack Mitchell, Houston
L-James Webb, Mississippi State
L-Randy White, Maryland
L-Michael Fanning, Notre Dame
L-Mike Hartenstine, Penn State
L-Pat Donovan, Stanford
L-Jimmy Webb, Mississippi State
L-Leroy Cook, Alabama
MG-Gary Burley, Pittsburgh
MB-Louie Kelcher, Southern Methodist
LB-Rod Shoate, Oklahoma
LB-Woodrow Lowe, Alabama
LB-Kenneth Bernich, Auburn
LB-Richard Wood, Southern California
B-John Provost, Holy Cross
B-Dave Brown, Michigan
B-Pat Thomas, Texas A&M
B-Randy Rhino, Georgia Tech